“If I’m a Christian, Why Am I Depressed?” + LINKUP


If I am a Christian, Why am I Depressed?Welcome to Mondays @ Soul Survival. Each week I feature a book that I consider a valuable resource. This week’s selection is If I’m a Christian, Why Am I Depressed?: Finding Meaning and Hope in the Dark Valley One Man’s Journey by Robert B. Somerville.


Christians and depression: We don’t often think both of those words should describe us. Yet, for some us, that is or has been our experience. Robert Somerville has written a great resource, describing a dark time in his life, the stories of others, and the hope found in Christ, the Gospel, and the Word of God.

From Somerville’s introduction:

I am endeavoring in this book to write about what I experienced and what I learned in the one foray into deep depression through which I journeyed. I pray that I will never have to pass that way again! It was a dreadful experience, some of which is hard to remember because I was so far out of it so as not to have a clear recollection of it. Many other parts are hard to remember because it is humbling to think of the wildness and incoherence of my thoughts and doubts. The chapter titles are the questions that I wrestled with.

When C.S. Lewis set out to write his autobiography Surprised by Joy he said “I have been emboldened to write of it because I notice that a man seldom mentions what he had supposed to be his own most idiosyncratic sensations without receiving from at least one (often more) of those present the reply, ‘What! Have you felt that too? I always thought I was the only one.’”1

How encouraging it is for those struggling with faith to read how Lewis was dragged by God over the threshold of faith, kicking and screaming and went on to inspire faith in millions! Likewise, each time I speak on the subject of depression and share some of my most humbling and even reviling thoughts that went through my mind in the depths of the depression, I have at least one (often more) come to me following the session and state “I have had those same thoughts! I know how you felt because I have been there! I have never shared my thoughts with anyone else because I didn’t think anyone would understand, and I believed I would be condemned!”

Could you be that one? Have you struggled with the dark feelings of depression?

If I'm a Christian, Why am I Depressed?

If not, you probably know someone who has. Many struggle alone. Many turn solely to medical help. Sadly, many, even those who are Christians, do not fully understand what Somerville learned in his dark valley:

Remember that you are not alone in your struggle against depression. Statistics indicate that this year alone, millions of Americans will suffer mild to severe depression. With that in mind I have shared the stories of others whom God has brought across our path, who have come out on the other side or who are still in the battle with depression. Read their stories and be encouraged! They are warriors who have also learned to put their hope in our faithful God. May their stories give you courage to take heart and fight on! I trust that these subjective thoughts on the subject of my depression and the objective teachings from the Word of God which are presented will encourage you to trust in the God who is there and who can truly surprise us by the joy of the Gospel. In the midst of depression, we may not have the feelings of joy, but it is there in seed form because of the knowledge that He loves us and will never leave us or forsake us. That is one objective fact of the universe.

Many great men of faith struggled with bouts of depression: Martin Luther, the great reformer; David Brainerd, the missionary to the American Indians; William Cowper, the prolific hymn writer; and Charles Spurgeon, the prince of preachers, just to name a few.

We understand that depression is a snare that has been trapping men and women throughout history and into our present age. It appears that women are more likely than men to experience a major depression probably because of the hormone fluctuations they experience at various stages in life.

Depression comes to Christians and non-Christians alike, the weak and the strong. We are not only spiritual beings; God has made us of clay—vulnerable to weakness, sin, disease, and yes, depression.

These are some of the questions with which the author wrestled:

  • If I’m a Christian, Why am I Depressed?
  • Where’s the hope?
  • How do I handle my guilt?
  • How do I deal with my fear, worry, and anxiety?
  • How do I express my grief to God?
  • Is joy out of the question?

Another chapter deals with the question:

  • How does the caregiver cope?

Along with his story, the author includes stories about post-partum depression, a college student’s story, depression because of sin, depression in the midst of battles with chronic pain, betrayal, disappointment, and others issues.

Those struggling with depression or wishing to help those who are will find great hope in Somerville’s book because it is grounded in God’s Word and the hope that, ultimately, only He can provide.

Jeremiah described it so well when he said, “Peace has been stripped away, and I have forgotten what prosperity is. I cry out, ‘My splendor is gone! Everything I had hoped for from the Lord is lost! The thought of my suffering is bitter beyond words. I will never forget this awful time, as I grieve over my loss’” (Lam. 3:17-20 NLT).

But as the Psalmist learned:

Weeping may endure for a night,
But joy comes in the morning. (Ps. 30.5b).




Quotations taken from:
Somerville, Robert B. (2014-08-28). If I’m a Christian, Why Am I Depressed?: Finding Meaning and Hope in the Dark Valley One Man’s Journey. Xulon Press. Kindle Edition.

You can get a copy of If I’m a Christian, Why Am I Depressed? or shop for other resources here.

Previously featured books:

Taming the To-Do List: How to Choose Your Best Work Every Day by Glynnis Whitwer. Read about it here.

Resolving Everyday Conflict by Ken Sande of Peacemaker Ministries. Read about it here.

Ordering Your Private World by Gordon MacDonald. Read about it here.

Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy by Eric Metaxas. Read about it here.

When Life Is Hard by James MacDonald. Read about it here.

Pleasing People: How Not to be an Approval Junkie by Lou Priolo. Read about it here.

Because He Loves Me: How Christ Transforms Our Daily Life by Elyse Fitzpatrick. Read about it here.

Gift-Wrapped by God: Secret Answers to the Question “Why Wait?” by Linda Dillow and Lorraine Pintus. Read about it here.

The Heart of Anger: Practical Help for the Prevention and Cure of Anger in Children by Lou Priolo. Read about it here.

Sweethearts for a Lifetime: Making the Most of Your Marriage by Wayne and Carol Mack. Read about it here.



Christian bloggers linkup

Mondays @ Soul Survival is a place to share your insights about God and His Word, parenting, marriage, homemaking, organization and more. Feel free to link up multiple posts as long as they are family friendly. Remember this is a Christian site. I would love it if you link back in someway and share the linkup on social media. I pin many of your posts on my “Mondays @ Soul Survival” Pinterest board as time allows.

Sign up for reminders of this LINKUP and Christian Living posts here.


I sometimes LINKUP with these blogs:

Mondays Making Your Home Sing Darling Downs Diaries The Modest Mom The Art of Homemaking Musing Mondays The Beauty in His Grip Our Home of Many Blessings
Tuesdays Time Warp Wife Testimony Tuesdays Purposeful Faith Grammie Time Cornerstone Confessions Tell It to Me Tuesday
Wednesdays A Wise Woman Builds Her Home Coffee for Your Heart Messy Marriage A Little R & R Whole Hearted Home Women with Intention While I’m Waiting Woman to Woman Seeking God in All I Do
Thursdays Hearts for Home Party at My Place Frog’s Lily Pad Life of Scoop
Fridays Create with Joy Missional Women Grace & Truth Family, Friendship & Faith
Saturdays Snippets of Inspiration Word of God Speak
Sundays Spiritual Sundays Raising Samuels Artful Homemaking

This post may contain affiliate links, but I only recommend books and resources that I believe are theologically sound and beneficial to the reader. Thank you for supporting this blog and ministry by supporting my links!

“Bible in a Year” posts have been edited and updated from previous posts.

12 thoughts on ““If I’m a Christian, Why Am I Depressed?” + LINKUP

  1. This sounds like an interesting book. I have experienced depression (when my caregiving season for my husband’s cancer journey ended I expected to feel elated over his recovery and felt guilty instead that I felt depressed), and our daughter struggled for almost eight months with unrelenting depression. I get a little tetchy when someone suggests that we can overcome depression through prayer and faith in God alone. God gave us helpers and healers who can guide us through the process much more quickly (and sometimes, as in the case of my daughter, the depression was a sign of something worse that only medicine can modify).

    • Yes, there are times when medicine is part of the process, but in many cases it only helps control the symptoms (which is important sometimes). And in almost all cases there are things God is doing in us. Thanks for sharing your story. Blessings!

  2. This sounds like a terrific book. I think this is something that goes on and is not talked about, which only hurts the person suffering even more. Thanks for sharing about this book and your amazing linkup with #SocialButterflySunday! Hope to see you link up again this week 🙂

  3. Donna, thank you for this post. I will pass this book recommendation on to my friend who has suffered through post partum depression this year. It took her a long time to seek diagnosis for what was actually going on, for many of the reasons touchd upon here. She is a wonderful Christian mother, wife, and friend…it was humbling to me that of all people she could suffer from this. It truly can happen to anyone. THank you for this. Happy Tuesday!

  4. I read your post looking for answers and was a bit disappointed it didn’t reveal more. While I’m glad many great people have suffered like I do and I’m therefore not alone, I’m not convinced that Christianity and getting depression are areas to be linked. While I acknowledge that God can be the hand that helps you up, true depression is a medical issue requiring medical help. Your faith should not be challenged because you have depression.

    • Suzi, I’m sorry you were disappointed. The author’s point is that you CAN be a Christian and still struggle with depression. He had been a Christian for many years when he went through a very dark time in his life.

      There certainly can be medical issues that contribute to depression, but not all depression is medical. Even when it is, there is still a spiritual component to how we respond to it. It’s a very broad topic and had to cover in a short post or in this case comment. I hope you will consider reading the book. I think it has much to offer you. There is also some great free audio information at the Institude for Biblical Counseling and Discipleship website.

      Thanks for sharing your thoughts.


  5. Hi, this sounds like such an important book for pastors and church leaders so that they understand and empathize with those in their flock who suffer depression. It is something all of us can identify with. Each of us have loved ones or we, ourselves, sometimes suffer from depression.

    • You’re right, Mary. It’s so encouraging to know we’re not alone and that others, including great men and women of faith, have suffered with depression. And, as you said, if we haven’t gone through a truly dark time, it gives us compassion for those who have or are. Have a great week-end!

  6. As I read your post I was reminded of the Bible “Greats” who struggled with depression- David, Elijah, and many more! Paul even talks about a thorn in his flesh. Something that he prayed would go away, but wouldn’t. I’m so glad you revealed the lie that because you are a Christian you shouldn’t be depressed. It’s that lie that can make people doubt their faith. They feel something is wrong with them, so they must not be saved or that Christianity doesn’t work because they feel that way. I believe these lies further oppress those suffering. Thanks for sharing today @ Faith Filled Friday.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *